Prep Room
Sign inCreate account
Coach note

Interviewers ask this kind of question to surface how you think, not what you remember. The strongest answers are specific, calmly told, and end on what changed.

Create an account or sign in to see model answers and concept guides, and to track the questions you’ve practiced.

Create free accountSign in
Communication & influence · Async influence

A peer reviewer has sent back sharp, partly unfair criticism of your submitted paper, and the editor is waiting on your response. How do you write the response letter to move the reviewer without conceding the parts you believe are right?

0of ~160 wordsAbout a minute spoken
Type your answer

Voice isn’t supported in this browser. Type your answer in the box.

Create a free account to get more critiques.

Your answer
Your answer appears here as you speak.
Model answerFree with an account

I write the letter for two readers — the reviewer, who needs to feel heard, and the editor, who's deciding — and tone does most of the work.…

The full answer: structure, worked example, likely follow-up.

Next Communication & influence question

Practice more

Thousands of questions, calibrated to your role. Your progress is saved across every session, with model answers and full breakdowns.

Create accountTour Prep Room

© Prep Room. This question is part of the Prep wiki. You’re welcome to quote it with a link to this page.